top of page

To Sell or Buy First: A Comprehensive Guide to Making the Right Real Estate Decision

The decision to sell your current house and buy a new one is a significant one that can have a profound impact on your financial well-being and lifestyle. Many homeowners find themselves grappling with the question, "Should I sell my house or buy a new one first?" On one hand, you don't want to risk being without a home if you sell your current house before finding a new one. On the other hand, you don't want to miss out on your dream home if you can’t buy it before selling your current one.

can i sell my house and buy a new one

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, as individual circumstances and market conditions play a crucial role in determining the best course of action. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or a seasoned homeowner looking to upgrade, join us as we navigate through the complexities of the real estate market and find the best strategy for your unique situation.


Option 1: Sell First

Selling your house first: Pros and cons

When it comes to selling your house first, there are several advantages and disadvantages to consider. On the plus side, selling your house before buying a new one allows you to have a clear understanding of your financial situation. However, selling your house first also comes with its drawbacks.

Despite these potential challenges, many homeowners choose to sell their house first as it provides a sense of financial security and allows for a smoother transition to the new home. By having the funds from the sale in hand, you can confidently search for your dream home without the added pressure of making a quick decision.

Advantages of Selling First

Financial Clarity: Selling your current house first allows you to have a clear understanding of how much money you have available to invest in a new property. By knowing the exact sale price of your current home, you can avoid overextending yourself and make a realistic budget for your new purchase.

Strong Negotiating Position: When you sell your house first, you become a more attractive buyer in the eyes of sellers. Your offer will be more appealing since you are not contingent on selling your current home. This can give you an edge in competitive markets.

No Pressure to Settle: Selling your house first allows you to take your time in finding the right new home. You won't feel pressured to accept an offer that doesn't meet your needs or settle for a house that doesn't truly suit you.

sell house first or buy house first

Disadvantages of Selling First

Temporary Housing: If your current home sells quickly and you haven't found a new one yet, you may need to arrange for temporary housing. This could mean staying with family or friends, renting, or even using short-term accommodations.

Double Moving Costs: Selling first may lead to two moves in a short period, which can be expensive and time-consuming. You will need to consider the cost of moving and storage for your belongings in between homes.

Market Fluctuations: Real estate markets can be unpredictable, and there is a risk that the market could change between the time you sell your house and find a new one. You may end up paying more for a new home in a hot market.


Option 2: Buy First

Buying your dream home first: Pros and cons

On the flip side, buying your dream home first offers its own set of advantages and disadvantages. If you come across your ideal property, you may be tempted to jump on the opportunity and secure it before it's gone. However, there are risks involved in buying your dream home before selling your current one.

Despite potential drawbacks, buying your dream home first can be a strategic move if you're confident in your ability to sell your current house quickly. It allows you to secure the property you desire without the uncertainty of finding a suitable home after selling. However, it's crucial to carefully assess your financial situation and market conditions before taking this leap.

Advantages of Buying First

No Temporary Housing Needed: Buying first eliminates the need for temporary housing, providing a smooth transition from one home to the next. You can move directly into your new home without the hassle of moving twice.

Time to Renovate: If you buy a fixer-upper or a property that needs some work, purchasing first gives you the flexibility to complete renovations before moving in. This way, you can personalize your new home without feeling rushed.

Emotional Security: Knowing that you have secured your new home before selling your current one can provide emotional security and peace of mind during the selling process.

Disadvantages of Buying First

Financing Challenges: Buying a new home before selling your current one can be financially challenging. You may need to qualify for a new mortgage while still carrying the existing mortgage. This situation can be riskier, especially if your current home takes longer to sell than anticipated.

Carrying Two Mortgages: If your current home takes time to sell, you will have to manage two mortgage payments simultaneously. This can put a strain on your finances and create additional stress. You'll need to ensure that you have enough income and savings to cover both mortgage payments until you sell your existing house.

Contingency Offers: If you need to make a contingent offer on your new home, it may be less appealing to sellers, especially in a competitive market. Sellers might prefer non-contingent offers for a smoother transaction.


Additional Options and Creative Solutions

If you find yourself torn between selling your house first and buying your dream home first, there are creative solutions available. To mitigate the financial impact of each choice, you can explore options such as bridge loans, rent-back agreements or other rental strategies. Each of these scenarios are detailed below.

Bridge Financing

Bridge financing is a financial solution that can help you bridge the gap between selling your current home and buying a new one. It is a short-term loan that covers the down payment on your new home until the sale of your old home is finalized. This option can provide financial flexibility, but it comes with its own set of considerations, including interest rates and potential risks.

Renting Out Your Current Home

If you don’t have to sell or if you’d like to turn your current home into an income-producing investment, you could rent out your current home. The benefit of this option is that the rental income would help offset or maybe even cover your mortgage payments on your new home. If you’d like to learn more about this strategy, sign up for our free email series.

Rent Back Agreements

Rent-back agreements allow you to negotiate an arrangement with the buyer of your current house to rent it back from them for a certain period. This can give you extra time to find a new home without the pressure of rushing into a purchase. Rent-back agreements can provide flexibility and peace of mind, allowing you to move at your own pace and avoid the stress of temporary housing.

Renting a New Home

Renting a property temporarily after selling your current home might be an option if you haven't found the right new home yet. Renting can provide you with more time to search for your dream home without rushing into a purchase. However, it may involve additional moving and storage costs and the inconvenience of temporary housing.


Important Factors to Consider

When standing at the crossroads of real estate decisions, it is essential to weigh the critical factors that will shape your path forward. Whether you are contemplating selling your house or buying a new one first, each choice holds its own set of implications that can profoundly impact your financial stability and emotional well-being. To navigate this pivotal moment with confidence and clarity, it is crucial to delve into several key considerations that will guide you towards the most suitable choice for your unique circumstances.

Market Conditions: Analyze the current real estate market in your area. Is it a seller's market with high demand and low inventory, or a buyer's market with more available homes Understanding the market conditions can influence your decision. While market trends and predictions can provide valuable insights, it's crucial not to rely solely on them when making your decision. Every market is unique, and individual circumstances can override general trends.

Financial Situation: Assess your financial stability and capacity to handle two mortgages if you decide to buy first. Consider your cash reserves, credit score, and the potential risk involved.

Timeline: Determine your preferred timeline for moving. Are you in a hurry to move into a new home, or can you afford to take your time?

should you buy or sell your house first

Emotional Factors: Consider how each option will affect you emotionally. Are you comfortable with the uncertainty of selling first, or do you prefer the security of buying first?

Personal Circumstances: Examine your current circumstances and lifestyle preferences. Are you in a rush to move into your dream home, or are you willing to wait for the right opportunity? Do you have a backup plan in case your current house doesn't sell as quickly as you anticipated?

Contingency Offers: If you need to make a contingent offer, understand how it might impact your chances in a competitive market.


​Conclusion: Finding the Right Path for Your Unique Circumstances

The decision of whether to sell your house or buy a new one first depends on your individual circumstances, risk tolerance, and preferences. There are advantages and disadvantages to both options, as well as potential middle-ground solutions like bridge financing and renting. It's crucial to carefully consider market conditions, your financial situation, and emotional factors before making a decision.

Remember, there is no one-size-fits-all answer to the sell-first-or-buy-first dilemma. Each individual's circumstances and goals are unique, and what works for one person may not work for another. Seeking professional guidance can help you navigate the complexities of the real estate market and make an informed choice that aligns with your long-term goals and aspirations.


bottom of page